EVAL Appeals are governed by BUPERS INST 1610.10D – Chapter 17. Appeals to the Chain of Command are handled internally through a Sailor’s chain of command. You may formally or informally appeal your negative EVAL. An informal appeal is a request that goes up to but not including your commanding officer. A formal appeal is requested through a special request chit requesting mast from your commanding officer. Appeals are adjudicated within the “lifelines” of a sailor's command. If a sailor does not agree with the decision after an appeal the sailor can submit a statement, request to correct the record or level a complaint against his commanding officer.
There is no timeline associated with submitting an appeal to the chain of command; however, you want to submit the appeal while the matter is still current and before your chain of command has transferred. If you are appealing an EVAL and the reporting senior has already transferred, your options are limited.
Once a formal appeal is submitted via a special request chit, the chit goes up the chain of command to the Commanding Officer. He then decides whether he will accept the mast deny the mast, or give the chain of command specific guidance in resolving the issue. If the Commanding Officer does accept the sailor’s mast the sailor will have an opportunity to make his argument directly to the CO and should expect an answer relatively quickly.
If both an informal appeal and formal appeal is unsuccessful, and the Sailor chooses to pursue the issue, his next step is to request a record correction through the Board of Correction of Naval Records or an Article 138/1150 complaint.
If you receive a negative EVAL, you are entitled to submit a written appeal. Follow applicable instructions. It is important that you submit a professional, respectful, and persuasive appeal.
We get this question all the time -- why should you buy our product when you can get a template from your friend, supervisor, or chain of command for free? The answer is simple:
#1. Our products were designed by former military officers, each with a Master’s degree. They’re not just recycled templates from your friends or supervisors (which probably didn’t work in the first place).
#2. Our products are built with your case in mind. We give you specific examples of “best practices” that help you win your case.
#3. Our products are properly formatted, so you don’t have to worry about making sure it looks professional. It already does!
Bottom line -- our products are specifically designed by experienced military officers to help you get the best result!
Military Justice Guides and MilitaryJusticeGuides.com are not law firms, nor do our employees act as legal counsel. MilitaryJusticeGuides.com provides an online portal to give users a general understanding of military law and to provide an automated software solution to individuals who choose to prepare their own documents. MilitaryJusticeGuides.com Services may also include a review of your answers for completeness, spelling, grammar, and for internal consistency of names, addresses and the like. At no time do we review your answers for legal sufficiency, draw legal conclusions, provide legal advice, opinions or recommendations about your legal rights, remedies, defenses, options, selection of forms, or strategies, or apply the law to the facts of your particular situation. We are not a law firm and may not perform services performed by an attorney. Military Justice Guides and MilitaryJusticeGuides.com, its related Services, and its forms or templates are not a substitute for the advice or services of an attorney.